Surgeon in Ohio dentist double murder allegedly used fake addresses to dodge lawsuits: 'He just disappeared'

Separate court filings show that Dr. Michael McKee was facing several allegations of medical malpractice and negligence in the months prior to being charged in the deaths of an Ohio dentist and his wife.

Federal court records reveal that McKee, a 39-year-old vascular surgeon, was named as a defendant in a civil rights and medical negligence lawsuit filed June 7, 2024, in U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada. In a separate matter, state court records in Clark County show that McKee is also the primary defendant in an active medical malpractice lawsuit slated for a jury trial.

According to Las Vegas-based lawyer Dan Laird, McKee managed to evade legal justice before he allegedly killed his ex-wife, Monique Tepe, 39, and her husband, Spencer Tepe, 37.

“They tend to be highly responsible people,” he told WSYX. “They’re not the kind of people who just disappeared suddenly, and this was very surprising to us.”

FAMILY ‘QUICKLY BELIEVED’ SURGEON EX WAS INVOLVED IN OHIO DENTIST COUPLE’S MURDER AS CO-WORKER DETAILS MISHAPS

Laird told WSYX that in a 2023 lawsuit, reviewed by Fox News Digital, McKee allegedly failed to train a physician’s assistant, leading to a patient being injured during treatment and needing emergency surgery.

The lawyer said that he was duped when McKee allegedly gave fake addresses and “questionable” state-issued phone numbers.

“Interestingly, the address that was given to us by the surgery group that he worked for turned out to be a fake address,” Laird told the local outlet, referencing Las Vegas Surgical Associates LLP. “It was an address that doesn’t exist.”

Laird shared that he repeatedly, for years, made efforts to contact McKee, even going to former colleagues, including Dr. Peter Caravella, who is also listed in the malpractice suit. Fox News Digital has reached out to Laird for additional details.

“He said he has no idea where Dr. Michael McKee is now,” Laird said. “He just disappeared.”

He just disappeared.

— Dan Laird, Las Vegas-based lawyer

READ THE LAWSUIT – APP USERS, CLICK HERE

The lawsuits were active in the months leading up to the deaths of the Ohio couple. Rob Misleh, Spencer’s brother-in-law, told NBC News that their family “quickly believed” that McKee was somehow involved in their deaths.

“He was an emotionally abusive person when they were together, that is all I know,” Misleh said.

Attorney Lindsay Richards, a former prosecutor, told Fox News Digital that while the civil lawsuit provides context since it appears that “his life was certainly spiraling out of control.”

“The prosecutor will likely only look to the civil cases to see if there is any overlap in behavior or if it caused mounting pressure or stress for this suspect. It puts his life in context to paint a picture for a jury. Likely this won’t have much influence, if any, on the criminal case beyond just understanding circumstances.”

“It does look like his life was certainly spiraling out of control, which is likely the only reason the prosecution would use these civil cases,” she said.

McKee was arrested after allegedly killing the couple on Dec. 30, according to records. Police officers responded to a house located in Columbus’ Weinland Park neighborhood around 10 a.m. Dec. 30 and found the couple, both dead with gunshot wounds. 

FRANTIC 911 CALLS DETAIL MOMENTS BEFORE COLUMBUS DENTIST AND WIFE FOUND DEAD: ‘THERE’S A BODY’

In the Nevada lawsuit, an incarcerated man alleges that McKee, while serving on the Nevada Department of Corrections’ Medical Review Panel, knowingly delayed medical care for a serious condition.

According to the complaint, reviewed by Fox News Digital, the plaintiff experienced ongoing pain and complications over an extended period and underwent multiple procedures that were allegedly ineffective.

SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER

The lawsuit claims approval for appropriate specialist care was repeatedly delayed despite the plaintiff’s worsening condition. As a result, the complaint alleges, the plaintiff ultimately suffered permanent injury, including the loss of a testicle. McKee and the other defendants named in the federal case deny the allegations. The claims have not yet been ruled on by the court.

Neither the federal civil rights lawsuit nor the state malpractice case has reached a resolution. 

SEND US A TIP HERE

Both Nevada cases were active during roughly the same period that McKee would later be charged in Ohio in connection with the deaths of his ex-wife and her husband. Authorities in Ohio have charged McKee with two counts of murder.

LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? FIND MORE ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

McKee was booked at the Winnebago County Sheriff’s Office in Illinois just before noon Saturday.

He’s facing upgraded premeditated aggravated murder charges in Ohio in relation to Spencer and Monique’s deaths.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

According to a document obtained by Fox News’ Bryan Llenas, McKee will not be transported to Franklin County, Ohio, by Monday, Jan. 19. The document said that the transport “will not be feasible,” and the court date previously set for Monday, Jan. 19, at 2 p.m. is canceled. A new date has been tentatively set for Jan. 23 at 2 p.m.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

Fox News Digital’s Adam Sabes and Bryan Llenas contributed to this report.